J
johnb
Guest
Back in the late 70s-early80s I was Head of Middle School in a prestigious, selective London day school for boys. Corporal punishment had been wholesale before that but, in my time, was only performed by the Headmaster, recorded in a book and witnessed by...well, little old me.
Most of the boys preferred it to the alternatives, eg calling in parents or the educational psychologist. It was over and done with.
I have a clear and very strong memory of one particular young chap, aged around 13 at the time, I won't give his name though I still remember it, who had transgressed in such a way that a caning was the most appropriate punishment.
The Head called him in, with me as witness. "XXX", said the Head, "I am going to cane you, bend over that chair."
XXX replied, remember, 13 years old, "On the contrary, Sir, you are not. I disagree fundamentally with all forms of corporal punishment."
Head, "XXX, over that chair!"
XXX, "I am afraid not, Sir!"
He went free and other methods were used. I would love to meet that young chap again now, probably in his 50s, and shake him by the hand.
Most of the boys preferred it to the alternatives, eg calling in parents or the educational psychologist. It was over and done with.
I have a clear and very strong memory of one particular young chap, aged around 13 at the time, I won't give his name though I still remember it, who had transgressed in such a way that a caning was the most appropriate punishment.
The Head called him in, with me as witness. "XXX", said the Head, "I am going to cane you, bend over that chair."
XXX replied, remember, 13 years old, "On the contrary, Sir, you are not. I disagree fundamentally with all forms of corporal punishment."
Head, "XXX, over that chair!"
XXX, "I am afraid not, Sir!"
He went free and other methods were used. I would love to meet that young chap again now, probably in his 50s, and shake him by the hand.